Unfair Dismissal Procedures: Lessons from the FWC
Following proper unfair dismissal procedures is essential for every Australian business. A recent case before the Fair Work Commission (FWC) highlights the risks of getting it wrong. The Commission ruled that a company unfairly dismissed a long-term employee after a heated dispute over overtime pay. This case serves as a warning for employers who skip legal steps.
A Case Study on Unfair Dismissal Procedures
The worker had been with the company for over five years. On April 23, 2024, he questioned why the company refused to pay his overtime. The general manager reacted angrily. He immediately told the worker to return his company vehicle. This act effectively ended the worker’s employment without warning.
Because the manager provided no clarity, the worker sought a remedy under the Fair Work Act 2009. He claimed the company ignored standard unfair dismissal procedures.
Why the FWC Ruled the Dismissal Unfair
The FWC found that the employer failed to meet several legal standards. Specifically, the dismissal lacked procedural fairness. The Commission noted these critical errors:
- No Valid Reason: The employer did not provide a legitimate reason for the termination.
- No Opportunity to Respond: Management never gave the worker a chance to address their concerns.
- Missing Warnings: The company had no record of prior performance issues or formal warnings.
- Non-Compliance: The process did not follow the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.
Compensation for Improper Procedures
The FWC often prefers reinstatement. However, the company entered voluntary administration, making reinstatement impossible. Instead, the Commission awarded the worker eight weeks of pay. They based this amount on his five-year tenure and likely future employment.
Employer Takeaways: Improving Your Dismissal Process
This case proves that failing to follow unfair dismissal procedures leads to costly penalties. To protect your business, always follow these steps:
- Document Everything: Ensure you have a valid, written reason for any termination.
- Provide a Right of Reply: You must allow employees to respond to allegations before you fire them.
- Check the Code: Always verify that your actions align with the Fair Work Act.
In conclusion, legal risks are high when you ignore fair termination processes. By prioritizing clear communication and unfair dismissal procedures, you can avoid the FWC and protect your business.
For more information click here
